Purchasing a vehicle through private sale has its attractions, such as lower costs and face-to-face negotiations. However, it is also full of its own challenges, most particularly when the vehicle is faulty—labeled hereafter as a “lemon.” Private vehicle sales have unique legal terms compared to sales by dealers, making most customers uncertain if they are protected by lemon laws when private sales have gone badly.
In this article, let’s take a closer look at how lemon laws protect private sales, what qualifies a vehicle to be called a lemon, and how customers can protect themselves.
Lemon laws are consumer protection laws that provide remedies for the purchase of faulty or “lemon” vehicles. When a company is unable to cure a flaw after making good-faith repairs, it is required to replace or refund the vehicle. The laws apply to most vehicles, including automobiles, trucks, sport-utilities, motorcycles, motor homes, and all-terrain vehicles.
The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act of 1975, or the federal lemon law, protects customers around the nation whenever there is warranty fraud or fraud. To meet the requirements, customers need evidence of warranty coverage, attempted warranty repairs, and unrepaired defects. The law is, however, not applicable to repossessed vehicles, farm equipment, or boats; it only applies to consumer-owned vehicles with valid active warranties.
Driving home in a shiny new vehicle only to discover a significant flaw can be disappointing. California law defines a vehicle as a lemon if it meets specific conditions. The vehicle must have been purchased in California and fall within its original manufacturer’s warranty. The flaw must significantly lower the vehicle’s value or safety and remain after good-faith repairs have been made.
Typically, four will suffice to activate lemon law protections, but only two will suffice if the defects are critical safety issues. The Lemon law takes effect if the vehicle is out of operation for 30 or more days due to the same flaw.It’s important to remember that cars that were sold without a warranty or developed defects after the warranty is no longer valid might not meet eligibility requirements. The good consumer protection laws of California ensure that customers can demand refunds or replacements if they find irreparable defects.
Private sellers will generally have to provide
In some states, sellers are also required to carry out emission tests and provide a valid smog certificate to ensure that the vehicle is safe enough to sell.
The Federal Trade Commission mandates that sellers offer each secondhand vehicle with a buyer’s guide indicating whether it is sold ‘as is’ or under warranty, coverage of the cost of repairs, and major mechanical or electrical defects. Private sales of automobiles are mostly sold ‘as is,’ where the buyer acquires the vehicle’s condition on sale and forfeits legal claims on hidden defects discovered after sale.
Although buying ‘as is’ is hazardous, vendors are legally required to disclose defects that can pose safety hazards. Concealment of a latent flaw can give rise to fraud on behalf of the buyers, subject to evidence of misrepresentation in the signed sale contract.
If a private seller has an active warranty on his or her vehicle, the coverage can be passed on to the owner. Some producers have limitations, though, such as warranty restrictions on subsequent owners. The warranty will somewhat protect the vehicle, but it will never activate private sale lemon laws.
California’s lemon law, for example, is only applicable to dealership purchases that have a warranty by the manufacturer. Even where the manufacturer can’t repair defects after making good-faith efforts, private-sale customers can’t demand buyback or refunds through lemon laws.
Taking proactive action after purchasing a faulty vehicle can protect your rights and better prepare you for the experience of driving a lemon.
Understanding your rights in a private sale of your vehicle is important to ensure your interests are well taken care of. You can demand the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) to order your vehicle history report. The sellers also have a legal obligation to notify of defects or accidents that are within their know-how. A bill of sale is also your right, where it legalizes your sale by putting it in writing and also offering evidence of sale.
Proper documentation is critical in a private sale. A sales contract or bill of sale validates that ownership is passed lawfully and outlines terms of sale, such as purchase price, vehicle identification, and mileage readings. The contract also outlines the owner’s warranty or representations about the vehicle’s health. The owner’s careful reading of this document ensures accuracy and helps reduce disputes afterward.
Lemon law buyback provisions generally require producers to buy back defective vehicles. Private sales are excluded by most but not all of them, though. Awareness of what rules apply where you live can provide insight into your legal remedies if your vehicle is a lemon. Being aware of your options is what makes your purchase decision informed, possibly saving you money loss and loss of use of your vehicle in the long run.
Doing your homework before purchasing a vehicle from a private owner is critical to ensuring you do not buy a lemon. The following are key checks that you should perform before making your final decision.
Consult a good mechanic to have the engine inspected for potential defects. Some areas of interest are coolant leaks that can lead to a breakdown of the radiator or engine, running on low oil, incomplete combustion, evidenced by a smell of burning, and ignition issues like extended starts that can point to electrical or fuel system defects.
Verify that important documents are in order to avoid legal issues. The seller should hand over the registration certificate, invoice of car purchase, RTO form, clearance certificate, road tax certificate, emission certificate, and owner’s guidebook. These documents are important for making claims on warranties and for avoiding legal issues that might arise in the future.
Research the history of the vehicle using sources like vehiclehistory.gov or the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS) to learn its salvage and insurance loss history. Check that there are no outstanding recalls on the vehicle on the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) website.
Confirm the warranty of the vehicle by asking the seller if there is active or valid coverage. A valid warranty can pay off expensive repairs if there are defects. Ensure there is no lapsed or forfeited warranty through modification or neglect of servicing—re-check facts by cross-checking with the manufacturer if needed.
In 2009, Greg Dagher purchased a secondhand 2006 Ford F-350 on private sale with 12,500 mileage on it and two years of its express warranty left on it. The engine issues of the truck continued after numerous attempts at fixing them by Ford dealerships. As he asserted, the original owner’s warranty and statutory rights were transferred to him, making him eligible for remedies of replacement or restitution. The court, however, dismissed his petition on the rationale that private sales were excluded under lemon laws. The court held on appeal that though remedies under lemon law were out of bounds, Dagher had a right to sue Ford on breach of express warranty.
Understanding how lemon laws cover private sales is valuable if you are considering taking on the risks of purchasing a secondhand vehicle. While private sales are on an ‘as is’ basis, knowing your rights, making sure documentation is suitable, and knowing the laws that apply can protect you from fraud or misrepresentation. Being informed and taking initiative can ensure that risks are minimized and that you make an informed decision about your purchase.
Suspect your used car need legal guidance? Get in touch with Lemon My Vehicle.
Citations
$26,534 $24,110 $23,345 $23,000 $22,195 $22,000 $21,586 $21,550 $20,183 $20,000 $20,000 $19,411 $18,000 $18,000 $17,000 $16,000
Call (213) 531-2056